Which of the following is the BEST evidence to consider?

A nurse is seeking best evidence to educate the parents on the use of olive oil for skin care of newborns.

Which of the following is the BEST evidence to consider?
A . Studies that explored the experience of using olive oil
B . Studies that considered pediatrician opinion on using olive oil
C . Studies that assessed parent’s perception on the use of olive oil
D . Studies that compared the use of olive oil versus manufactured baby oils

View Answer

Answer: D

Explanation:

The best evidence for educating parents on the use of olive oil for newborn skin care would come from studies that directly compare the use of olive oil to other commonly used baby oils.

Studies that Explored the Experience of Using Olive Oil: These may provide qualitative insights but are not the strongest form of evidence for making recommendations.

Studies that Considered Pediatrician Opinion on Using Olive Oil: Expert opinion can be valuable but is less robust compared to direct comparative studies.

Studies that Assessed Parent’s Perception on the Use of Olive Oil: These provide subjective insights and are not as strong as objective comparisons of effectiveness and safety.

Studies that Compared the Use of Olive Oil Versus Manufactured Baby Oils: Comparative studies provide direct evidence on the effectiveness and safety of olive oil compared to other products, making them the most reliable source of evidence for making an informed recommendation.

Reference: Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing & Healthcare: A Guide to Best Practice Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Skincare Interventions for Infants