Is Carson correct with respect to defined contribution plans?

Andrew Carson is an equity analyst employed at Lee, Vincent, and Associates, an investment research firm. In a conversation with his supervisor, Daniel Lau, Carson makes the following two statements about defined contribution plans.

Statement 1: Employers often face onerous disclosure requirements.

Statement 2: Employers often bear all the investment risk.

Carson is responsible for following Samilski Enterprises (Samilski), a publicly traded firm that produces motorcycles and other mechanical parts. It operates exclusively in the United States. At the end of its 2009 fiscal year, Samilski’s employee pension plan had a projected benefit obligation (PBO) of $320 million. Also, unrecognized prior service costs were $35 million, the fair value of plan assets was $316 million, and the unrecognized actuarial gain was $21 million.

Carson believes the rate of compensation increase will be 5% as opposed to 4% in the previous year, and the discount rate will be 7% as opposed to 8% in the previous year.

This past year, Samilski began using special purpose entities (SPEs) for various reasons. In preparation for analyzing the SPE disclosures in the footnotes to the financial statements, Carson prepares a memo on SPEs. In the memo, he correctly concludes that the company will be required under new accounting rules to classify them as variable interest entities (VIE) and consolidate the entities on the balance sheet rather than report them using the equity method as in the past.

Is Carson correct with respect to defined contribution plans?
A . Both statements are incorrect.
B . Only Statement 1 is incorrect.
C . Only Statement 2 is incorrect.

Answer: A

Explanation:

Statement 1: Employers often face onerous disclosure requirements―incorrect; the accounting is quite simple and the onerous disclosure requirements are more characteristic of defined benefit plans.

Statement 2: Employers often bear all the investment risk―incorrect; benefits received by each individual employee on retirement depends on the investment performance of each individuals personal retirement fund. Thus, the employees bear the investment risk.

Therefore, both statements arc incorrect. (Study Session 6, LOS 22.a)