CIPS L4M5 Commercial Negotiation Online Training
CIPS L4M5 Online Training
The questions for L4M5 were last updated at Nov 19,2024.
- Exam Code: L4M5
- Exam Name: Commercial Negotiation
- Certification Provider: CIPS
- Latest update: Nov 19,2024
Question #1
An oil refinery plant imports much of its crude oil from overseas. A procurement manager in the refinery suggests that fixing the crude oil contract price for 36 months would be beneficial for the company.
Would this be a right thing to do?
- A . Yes, financial budgeting task would be a lot easier with fixed pricing arrangement
- B . No, fixed price should be only applied to contracts that last 60 months or longer
- C . No, the refinery would not be able to reap the benefits from falling commodity price and currency rates
- D . Yes, the supplier would bear the risk when the material price increased
Correct Answer: C
C
Explanation:
Fixed price contract is the contract in which the price is static throughout the contract period. A fixed-price contract may give certainty to budget and simplify contract management. However, it may lead to other problems since it requires bidders to estimate and bear the financial risks associated with price escalations. If the estimates are too high or events do not materialize, the buyer will pay a steep price that may affect the economy and efficiency of the contract. In the worst case, it may mean that the bid price is then above budget and may lead to a reduction in the requirements or rebidding. If the estimates are too low, it may appear as an abnormally low bid and disrupt contract execution.
On the other hand, price adjustment provisions include formulas designed to address problems, and can protect both the borrower and contractors from price fluctuations. Price adjustment formulas allow contractors to offer more realistic prices at the time of bidding. Despite concerns that they may lead to budget uncertainties, price adjustment formulas will estimate the actual cost implications that will be encountered. They use indexes that can be used for cost projection.
According to Asia Development Bank (ADB), any contract with a delivery or completion period beyond 18 months should contain an appropriate price adjustment clause.
In the scenario, the crude oil contract is planned to last 36 months. This period is pretty long with a fluctuating commodity. Therefore, the company should use price adjustment agreement.
Reference:
– CIPS study guide page 113-117
– GuidanceNote on Procurement: Price Adjustment (adb.org) LO 2, AC 2.2
C
Explanation:
Fixed price contract is the contract in which the price is static throughout the contract period. A fixed-price contract may give certainty to budget and simplify contract management. However, it may lead to other problems since it requires bidders to estimate and bear the financial risks associated with price escalations. If the estimates are too high or events do not materialize, the buyer will pay a steep price that may affect the economy and efficiency of the contract. In the worst case, it may mean that the bid price is then above budget and may lead to a reduction in the requirements or rebidding. If the estimates are too low, it may appear as an abnormally low bid and disrupt contract execution.
On the other hand, price adjustment provisions include formulas designed to address problems, and can protect both the borrower and contractors from price fluctuations. Price adjustment formulas allow contractors to offer more realistic prices at the time of bidding. Despite concerns that they may lead to budget uncertainties, price adjustment formulas will estimate the actual cost implications that will be encountered. They use indexes that can be used for cost projection.
According to Asia Development Bank (ADB), any contract with a delivery or completion period beyond 18 months should contain an appropriate price adjustment clause.
In the scenario, the crude oil contract is planned to last 36 months. This period is pretty long with a fluctuating commodity. Therefore, the company should use price adjustment agreement.
Reference:
– CIPS study guide page 113-117
– GuidanceNote on Procurement: Price Adjustment (adb.org) LO 2, AC 2.2
Question #2
Jane is planning for a forthcoming negotiation with a key supplier. She has learned what are important to the supplier and what are important to her company from previous contracts between them. In order to avoid negotiation deadlocks, she has set up several concession plans. But Jane has little experience in dealing with suppliers and doesn’t know when to trade these concessions.
When is the best time in a negotiation to trade concessions?
- A . In the testing phase
- B . In the proposing phase
- C . At bargaining stage
- D . At opening stage
Correct Answer: C
C
Explanation:
The question asks about the point in time when Jane should make concessions with the supplier. These concessions should be traded after preliminary stages such as opening, testing and proposing are over and proposals move from being tentative and general to being more definite and specific. This stage is called bargaining phase. The bargaining phase is the ‘meat’ of the negotiation meeting. LO 3, AC 3.1
C
Explanation:
The question asks about the point in time when Jane should make concessions with the supplier. These concessions should be traded after preliminary stages such as opening, testing and proposing are over and proposals move from being tentative and general to being more definite and specific. This stage is called bargaining phase. The bargaining phase is the ‘meat’ of the negotiation meeting. LO 3, AC 3.1
Question #3
Which of the following are examples of push techniques in commercial negotiations? Select TWO that apply.
- A . Threat of punishment, costs and damage
- B . Listening to, involving andsupporting others
- C . Argument based on information, logic and reason
- D . Working together to define the problem, the goals and the best solution
- E . Using language and imagery to ‘paint a picture others can see’
Correct Answer: A,C
A,C
Explanation:
There are two major persuasion methods: ‘push’ and ‘pull’.
Persuasion can be defined as encouraging someone to do something that you want them to do for you. Persuasion is reasoning with someone so that they will believe or do something they might not otherwise do. Persuasion can be considered as ‘pushing’ on TOP so that they can accept the change in attitude or behaviour as a result of your actions. Influence is the ability to affect the manner of thinking of another. Influence can be considered as pulling on TOP so that you achieve the same result, but TOP feels they have changed their attitude or behaviour as a result of their reflection and thinking, and not your direct actions.
There are 5 options in this question:
‘Threat of punishment, costs and damage’: The influencertries to ‘push’ the other party to act as he/she wants by using force. This method is effective but short-lived. The influencer also risks to developing reputation for being heavy handed and dictatorial.
‘Argument based on information, logic and reason’: The influencer uses logic and reasons to persuade the other party. This is also known as ‘Persuasive Reasoning’ (Push) ‘Using language and imagery to ‘paint a picture others can see’’: The influencer seeks to influence another by understanding the other’s emotions, and stimulating that party’s imagination to visualise the desired future goal of the influencer. This is also known as ‘visionary (pull)’
‘Working together to define the problem, the goals and the best solution’: In this technique, the person seeking to influence another involves the other party in the decision making process. This is known as ‘collaborative (pull)’
‘Listening to, involving and supporting others’: In this technique, the person seeking to influence another tries to discover the other party’s emotion and aims at mutual understanding. This is also a collaborative approach.
A,C
Explanation:
There are two major persuasion methods: ‘push’ and ‘pull’.
Persuasion can be defined as encouraging someone to do something that you want them to do for you. Persuasion is reasoning with someone so that they will believe or do something they might not otherwise do. Persuasion can be considered as ‘pushing’ on TOP so that they can accept the change in attitude or behaviour as a result of your actions. Influence is the ability to affect the manner of thinking of another. Influence can be considered as pulling on TOP so that you achieve the same result, but TOP feels they have changed their attitude or behaviour as a result of their reflection and thinking, and not your direct actions.
There are 5 options in this question:
‘Threat of punishment, costs and damage’: The influencertries to ‘push’ the other party to act as he/she wants by using force. This method is effective but short-lived. The influencer also risks to developing reputation for being heavy handed and dictatorial.
‘Argument based on information, logic and reason’: The influencer uses logic and reasons to persuade the other party. This is also known as ‘Persuasive Reasoning’ (Push) ‘Using language and imagery to ‘paint a picture others can see’’: The influencer seeks to influence another by understanding the other’s emotions, and stimulating that party’s imagination to visualise the desired future goal of the influencer. This is also known as ‘visionary (pull)’
‘Working together to define the problem, the goals and the best solution’: In this technique, the person seeking to influence another involves the other party in the decision making process. This is known as ‘collaborative (pull)’
‘Listening to, involving and supporting others’: In this technique, the person seeking to influence another tries to discover the other party’s emotion and aims at mutual understanding. This is also a collaborative approach.
Question #4
Which of the following is the internal factor that is taken intoprice of a product?
- A . Risk management
- B . Customer tastes
- C . Elasticity
- D . Exchange rate
Correct Answer: A
A
Explanation:
In order to answer this question, you should better consider each option:
‘Exchange rate’ is the value of one nation’s currency versus the currency of another nation or economic zone. This is a macroeconomic factor.
‘Elasticity’ refers to the degree to which individuals, consumers or producers change their demand or the amount supplied in response to price or income changes. This is a microeconomic factor Consumer tastes refer to the products and services that consumers consciously choose over others. Consumer tastes are so powerful that they can change how businesses
conduct their activity. Like elasticity, this is also a microeconomic factor.
Among 4 options, only risk management is the internal factor. Risk pricing is a strategy applied by many companies in the world. To learn how to price the risk, you can read an article from McKinsey: https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/marketing-and-sales/our-insights/how-to-price-risk-to-win-and-profit
This is a question that a student met in her actual exam. The knowledge section is unknown.
LO: Unknown, AC: Unknown
A
Explanation:
In order to answer this question, you should better consider each option:
‘Exchange rate’ is the value of one nation’s currency versus the currency of another nation or economic zone. This is a macroeconomic factor.
‘Elasticity’ refers to the degree to which individuals, consumers or producers change their demand or the amount supplied in response to price or income changes. This is a microeconomic factor Consumer tastes refer to the products and services that consumers consciously choose over others. Consumer tastes are so powerful that they can change how businesses
conduct their activity. Like elasticity, this is also a microeconomic factor.
Among 4 options, only risk management is the internal factor. Risk pricing is a strategy applied by many companies in the world. To learn how to price the risk, you can read an article from McKinsey: https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/marketing-and-sales/our-insights/how-to-price-risk-to-win-and-profit
This is a question that a student met in her actual exam. The knowledge section is unknown.
LO: Unknown, AC: Unknown
Question #5
A procurement professional is negotiating with a supplier on cleaning service. She realises that there are huge cost-saving opportunities if the supplier agrees to reduce its mark-up and unnecessary employee benefits. Supplier’s mark-up and employee benefits are examples of which of the following?
- A . Spend waterfall
- B . Spend cube
- C . Spend tree
- D . Addressable spend
Correct Answer: D
D
Explanation:
A key consideration when seeking to negotiate prices is to establish what proportion of the spend is addressable by procurement action such as negotiation. Addressability of spend is influenceable through negotiations or application of other saving effort or leverage with suppliers. LO 2, AC 2.1
D
Explanation:
A key consideration when seeking to negotiate prices is to establish what proportion of the spend is addressable by procurement action such as negotiation. Addressability of spend is influenceable through negotiations or application of other saving effort or leverage with suppliers. LO 2, AC 2.1
Question #6
Which of the following are signs indicating that TOP is using coercive power in commercial negotiation? Select TWO that apply.
- A . Demonstrating fairness and respect
- B . Withdrawal of benefits
- C . Use of guilt
- D . Technical expertise
- E . Positive references
Correct Answer: B,C
B,C
Explanation:
Coercive power comes from the belief that a person can punish other for non-compliance, and can be considered as the flip side of reward power. Coercive power rests in the individual’s ability to change other people’s behaviour through threat,intimidation, use of guilt, ability to embarrass or shame, or withdrawal of benefits,…
B,C
Explanation:
Coercive power comes from the belief that a person can punish other for non-compliance, and can be considered as the flip side of reward power. Coercive power rests in the individual’s ability to change other people’s behaviour through threat,intimidation, use of guilt, ability to embarrass or shame, or withdrawal of benefits,…
Question #7
Ma Bell was the sole provider of landline telephone service to most of the US in 1980s.
This is an example of…?
- A . Monopsony
- B . Monopoly
- C . Monopolistic competition
- D . Perfect competition
Correct Answer: B
B
Explanation:
A monopoly exists when only one company can supply an essential product or service in a givenregion because of significant barriers to entry for any competitor. The barriers can be legal, regulatory, economic, or geographic. Ma Bell case is an example of monopoly. The company was broken up in 1982.
A monopsony is a market structure in which a single buyer substantially controls the market as the major purchaser of goods and services offered by many would-be sellers.
Pure or perfect competition is a theoretical market structure in which the following criteria are met:
– All firms sell an identical product (the product is a "commodity" or "homogeneous").
– All firms are price takers (they cannot influence the market price of their product).
– Market share has no influence on prices.
– Buyers have complete or "perfect" information―in the past, presentand future―about the product being sold and the prices charged by each firm.
– Resources for such a labor are perfectly mobile.
– Firms can enter or exit the market without cost.
Monopolistic competition characterizes an industry in which many firms offerproducts or services that are similar, but not perfect substitutes. Barriers to entry and exit in a monopolistic competitive industry are low, and the decisions of any one firm do not directly affect those of its competitors. Monopolistic competition is closely related to the business strategy of brand differentiation
Reference: CIPS study guide page 105-110
LO 2, AC 2.2
B
Explanation:
A monopoly exists when only one company can supply an essential product or service in a givenregion because of significant barriers to entry for any competitor. The barriers can be legal, regulatory, economic, or geographic. Ma Bell case is an example of monopoly. The company was broken up in 1982.
A monopsony is a market structure in which a single buyer substantially controls the market as the major purchaser of goods and services offered by many would-be sellers.
Pure or perfect competition is a theoretical market structure in which the following criteria are met:
– All firms sell an identical product (the product is a "commodity" or "homogeneous").
– All firms are price takers (they cannot influence the market price of their product).
– Market share has no influence on prices.
– Buyers have complete or "perfect" information―in the past, presentand future―about the product being sold and the prices charged by each firm.
– Resources for such a labor are perfectly mobile.
– Firms can enter or exit the market without cost.
Monopolistic competition characterizes an industry in which many firms offerproducts or services that are similar, but not perfect substitutes. Barriers to entry and exit in a monopolistic competitive industry are low, and the decisions of any one firm do not directly affect those of its competitors. Monopolistic competition is closely related to the business strategy of brand differentiation
Reference: CIPS study guide page 105-110
LO 2, AC 2.2
Question #8
One difference between perfect competition and monopolistic competition is that…?
- A . In perfect competition, firms produce slightly differentiated products
- B . A perfectly competitive industry has fewer firms.
- C . Monopolistic competition has no barriers to entry
- D . Firms in monopolistic competition face a downward-sloping demand curve
Correct Answer: D
D
Explanation:
Monopolistic competition exists in market where there are many competing producers but they will try to use product differentiation. Although their products may be very similar, their ability to differentiate means that they can act as monopolies in short run, irrespective of the actions of their competitors.
In perfect competition, there are no barriers to entry to the market or exit from the market. In monopolistic competition, there tend to be fewer barriers to entry or exit in these markets than in oligopolistic markets, but it doesn’t mean that there are absolutely no barriers to entry in monopolistic competition.
In perfect competition, the demand curve is perfectly elastic, which means that it will be horizontal. Otherwise, in monopolistic competition market, the demand curve will have normal downward slope.
LO 2, AC 2.2
D
Explanation:
Monopolistic competition exists in market where there are many competing producers but they will try to use product differentiation. Although their products may be very similar, their ability to differentiate means that they can act as monopolies in short run, irrespective of the actions of their competitors.
In perfect competition, there are no barriers to entry to the market or exit from the market. In monopolistic competition, there tend to be fewer barriers to entry or exit in these markets than in oligopolistic markets, but it doesn’t mean that there are absolutely no barriers to entry in monopolistic competition.
In perfect competition, the demand curve is perfectly elastic, which means that it will be horizontal. Otherwise, in monopolistic competition market, the demand curve will have normal downward slope.
LO 2, AC 2.2
Question #9
Which of the following should be the final step of a negotiation process if both parties cannot reach an agreement?
- A . Reflecting on performance
- B . Tempting TOP to reopen the negotiation
- C . Asking TOP for another concession
- D . Celebrating publicly about the deal
Correct Answer: A
A
Explanation:
Reflecting on performance should become a natural final step in the negotiation process. ‘Celebrating publicly about the deal’: Public gloating, even in success or failure, if it gets back to the supplier via the press or social media, will likely damage the relationship ‘Tempting TOP to reopen the negotiation’: whether TOP agrees to reopen the negotiation, procurement should reflect on their achievement and what can be improved.
‘Asking TOP for another concession’: TOP can agree or rejectthis concession. Eventually, reflecting should be the final step. Procurement can learn a lot from reflection on performance.
LO 3, AC 3.4
A
Explanation:
Reflecting on performance should become a natural final step in the negotiation process. ‘Celebrating publicly about the deal’: Public gloating, even in success or failure, if it gets back to the supplier via the press or social media, will likely damage the relationship ‘Tempting TOP to reopen the negotiation’: whether TOP agrees to reopen the negotiation, procurement should reflect on their achievement and what can be improved.
‘Asking TOP for another concession’: TOP can agree or rejectthis concession. Eventually, reflecting should be the final step. Procurement can learn a lot from reflection on performance.
LO 3, AC 3.4
Question #10
Which of the following are most likely to help buyer become preferred customer in supplier’s perspective? Select TWO that apply.
- A . Onerous supplier terms and conditions
- B . Compliance with agreed repair lead time
- C . Shorter payment period
- D . Reduction in delivery errors
- E . Ensuring an increased number of repeat orders
Correct Answer: C,E
C,E
Explanation:
Becoming a preferred customer to supplier’s perspective can increase the purchaser’s leverage in negotiation.
Beside the size of buying organisation or its spend, the following may be sufficient to differentiate the buyer from other buying organisations:
– Simple procurement processes
– Simple contracting processes
– Clear and concise documentation
– Absence of onerous supplier terms and conditions (onerous supplier terms and conditions mean that obligations imposed on suppliers are greater than their gains)
– On-time payment: The reduction in hassle for both supplier and the buyer, if bills are paid on time, is significant. From the customer’s perspective it could also be the opener to agreeing preferential payment terms. A supplier may weigh up that payment on time at 60 days is worth taking, over the current 30-day terms that slip to 90 days and beyond.
– Transparent processes
– Ethical behavior
LO 1, AC 1.3
C,E
Explanation:
Becoming a preferred customer to supplier’s perspective can increase the purchaser’s leverage in negotiation.
Beside the size of buying organisation or its spend, the following may be sufficient to differentiate the buyer from other buying organisations:
– Simple procurement processes
– Simple contracting processes
– Clear and concise documentation
– Absence of onerous supplier terms and conditions (onerous supplier terms and conditions mean that obligations imposed on suppliers are greater than their gains)
– On-time payment: The reduction in hassle for both supplier and the buyer, if bills are paid on time, is significant. From the customer’s perspective it could also be the opener to agreeing preferential payment terms. A supplier may weigh up that payment on time at 60 days is worth taking, over the current 30-day terms that slip to 90 days and beyond.
– Transparent processes
– Ethical behavior
LO 1, AC 1.3
Latest L4M5 Dumps Valid Version with 162 Q&As
Latest And Valid Q&A | Instant Download | Once Fail, Full Refund
Subscribe
Login
0 Comments
